Sample grant review comments. NIH separates the review process from funding decisions.
Sample grant review comments. Also, though you don’t have to do it for my class; if you’re doing it for an actual journal, make sure to use department letterhead. You’ll find both positive recognition and constructive feedback organized by key workplace skills. D. Be consistent in your scoring. These comments, organized by rating levels, create consistency in performance management and enable fair After your grant is submitted and reviewed by a funding agency, you can expect to receive an official document with the outcome of their grant review. Performance Review Summary Templates and Examples A performance summary helps managers document While you must address all the reviewers' comments from your summary statement, you can start adding new data or making other improvements to the application. From constructive feedback to recognition phrases, these insights ensure fair, professional, and productive reviews. s a functional, reliable, and fair review process. Enhance your performance reviews with our comprehensive guide, offering effective tips for constructive feedback. What are its goals? b. Review comments should be limited to those that are required to ensure adequacy of the product; that is, comments that substantively improve the quality of the planning product, decision making, or project implementation. When referencing these examples, it is important to remember: Related: 200+ Performance Review Phrases for Professionalism, Collaboration and Cooperation, Punctuality Related: 26 Example Paragraphs for Performance Reviews [Positive & Negative Feedback] Mar 21, 2016 · Reviewers will provide an overall impact score to reflect their assessment of the likelihood for the project to exert a sustained, powerful influence on the research field(s) involved, in consideration of the following five scored review criteria, and additional review criteria. Jul 31, 2025 · 150 Performance Review Examples and Phrases for Giving Effective Feedback Providing structured feedback is essential for employee growth. Comments or feedback on any of the instruments or elements of this process? Thank you so much for your service to A collection of sample grant applications and other resources provided by NIAID investigators. It includes fictitious examples of weak and strong comments for each major section in the critique template; points highlighted in red around the periphery elaborate on why comments made in the critique are considered effective or not. The examples in this article can help create reviews that drive improvement. Jun 7, 2023 · To observe how other applicants approach grantsmanship, examine the text sections of the successful example applications—particularly the Specific Aims and Research Plans. In this article, we will explore the key SAMPLE RESPONSE TO REVIEWERS’ COMMENTS Below are actual comments to a review I wrote sometime ago. Best Practices for Responding to the Reviewers’ Comments in Resubmission Applications Jaime S. With that context in mind, let’s explore our 20 May 28, 2025 · From assembling to effectively managing your grant review committee, here are five best practices to get it right. Proposal review is one step in the NSF program planning and implementation process. Using the right phrases and examples helps managers give balanced feedback that encourages growth while acknowledging achievements. Grant Proposal Review Checklist This checklist is designed to serve as a guide for reviewing grant proposals. Jul 26, 2025 · Learn what a performance review is and 79 effective performance review phrases that you can use during your next employee review, arranged by common skills. His problem-solving skills make him valuable to the support team. It’s confusing for program officers when a reviewer only praises a project, offers no constructive criticism, but then gives the application a low score. Every time, I learn something different; it is one of the best forms of professional development available for grant writers. Applications will be reviewed by a grant selection committee appointed by Governor Polis. Performance Review Questions: Teamwork By asking yourself these questions and reflecting on the employee’s performance, you can better understand their strengths and areas for improvement in working collaboratively with their colleagues: 1. Explore our collection of over 100 practical employee evaluation comments examples. Enhance evaluations with insightful comments for growth and success. NERC Peer Reviewer Comments - assessment of the ORCHESTRA project NERC Peer Reviewer Comments - assessment of the ORCHESTRA project: 1. Aug 12, 2025 · CSR’s primary role is to handle the receipt and review of all grant applications that NIH receives. Supervisor Recommendations: Forward-looking comments that bridge current performance with future development opportunities and career pathways. Jul 30, 2025 · Use these powerful employee performance review phrases to help give targeted feedback that will motivate and drive better performance. The more you control the assessment experience, the less room you leave to subjectivity. Frequent comments from reviewers are summarized below to provide insights to potential applican To carry out our commitment to offer critical, constructive feedback to applicants, we rely on external reviewers to offer expert judgements to every grant reviewed. CWR will send you the full grant review materials, along with the review due date. Reviewers practice valuable leadership and teamwork skills along with seeing samples of good, bad, and downright ugly proposals. Excluding course final exams, content authored by Saylor Academy is available under a Creative Commons The review of grant proposals is at the heart of the NIH grants process. The committee will use this rubric to guide its deliberations. Part 1 Work Ethic Performance Review Comments Consistency and Reliability Evaluation Examples Strengths: Jul 3, 2024 · Self-Review Examples: Sample self-appraisal comments for employees writing their own performance reviews, including accomplishments and growth areas. The goal of the Grant Reviewing Workshop and Mock Proposal Review Session at the NIDUS Delirium Boot Camp is to train NIDUS mentees on The grant program’s financial manager will need to be present to answer those questions. They create lasting impressions that can motivate staff and shape future performance. Collaboration and Teamwork Positive comments that praise good teamwork: “You always support your What grant scoring system or criteria does your community foundation use? All sample documents have been posted at www. Performance evaluations shape career paths and motivate employees to reach their goals. Learn from the best and boost your online reputation today. An objective, third-party review and grant critique will give you a fresh perspective and will make your good proposal even better. Before completing their reviews, reviewers May 21, 2025 · 13 steps to becoming a great grant reviewer While scoring rubrics and review stages may vary across grant programs, there are some universal best practices for grant reviewers, no matter the size or complexity of the grant. To help you provide meaningful feedback, we’ve compiled 100 example phrases and comments categorized by skill area, behavior, and role expectations — perfect for 2025’s evolving workplace dynamics. Grant Reviewer Resume Samples A Grant Review works for the Government agencies and undertakes the crucial role of reviewing and rating grant applications. This proposal secured funding for community-based programming to raise awareness of cardiovascular disease prevention. Browse our blog for valuable insights on performance review examples. Well-crafted performance review phrases help managers deliver meaningful feedback while maintaining objectivity and professionalism during the evaluation process. Here, we'll look at the basic tenets of peer review, and we've provided a sample framework to help new reviewers give comments that will help authors strengthen their papers. . How well does the employee work with others in a Apr 21, 2023 · Understanding Common Grant Proposal Scoring Systems; A Comprehensive Guide with Practical Examples Grant proposals are a critical part of securing funding for many organizations and projects. Please comment on the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed research (i. It is important to note that not all sections or criteria will apply to all grant proposals. Never underestimate the value of having someone review and critique your grant proposal prior to submission. You can make them better and less stressful by knowing the right things to say, and this article gives you a list of simple comments you can use in reviews, sorted by the skills they relate to. The best closing comments blend praise with actionable feedback, helping workers feel both appreciated and challenged to reach new levels of success. Below I have provided Performance review closing comments put a strong finish on evaluations and leave employees with clear direction. Nov 2, 2023 · TEMPLATE Comments to Proposed Guidance for Grants and Agreements NOTE: Submitting public comments to federal rulemaking can be as easy as typing your thoughts into the comments box. These examples will help you write reviews that motivate your team and lead to improvements. Enhance your chances of success with our expert guidance. Apr 24, 2025 · Learn what performance evaluation phrases, why they're important in motivating employees, tips for writing them and examples of how to write effective feedback. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to submit a revised draft of the manuscript “Poetry and the Cognitive Psychology of Metrical Constructs” for publication in the Journal of Poetry and Psychology. Good feedback helps workers understand exactly what they do well and what needs work. Explore AI-driven grant review examples to improve proposal quality and funding chances with structured, insightful feedback and strategic revisions. If you cannot perform regular site visits, it is good practice to periodically review how your grantee(s) are performing. The employee evaluation process is an excellent opportunity for supervisors to provide helpful feedback to employees. The goal of peer review is to provide expert advice to NIH on the scientific and technical merit of grant applications to inform their funding decisions. Although each funding organization might have its own specific procedures, most follow a similar multi-step process. In this article, we review effective employee evaluation phrases that can be used in providing valuable feedback to employees. The guidelines of the grant application will be checked to ensure the format and review criteria have been appropriately addressed The proposal content will be scrutinized for viability, excellence of the idea, and all other scored aspects. We appreciate the time and effort that you and the reviewers dedicated to providing feedback on our manuscript and are grateful for the insightful comments on and valuable improvements to Sep 25, 2024 · Are you looking for the perfect way to express your gratitude to the reviewers who took the time to provide valuable feedback on your work? Sep 18, 2024 · Grant Application Examples: A Comprehensive Guide OpenGrantsIntroduction Understanding Grant Requirements: A Roadmap to Successful Funding Crafting a winning grant proposal requires a comprehensive understanding of grant requirements. Knowing the right phrases to use during an evaluation can have a positive impact on how the feedback is received and implemented. Research question/ statement of the problem/ program objectives Significance of research question Existing state of the field and gaps (literature) Methods Expected products/ outcomes/ contribution Assessment/ dissemination Saylor Academy © 2010-2025 except as otherwise noted. Comments (0 pts) Please include concerns or strengths about grant proposal to share with school/applicant, upon request. An important secondary goal is to provide constructive feedback to applicants for their resubmissions. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. General Comments from Reviewer 1 Comment: This is an interesting study and the authors have collected a unique dataset using cutting edge methodology. RISE Education Fund Scoring Rubric for Grant Proposals The grant proposal scoring rubric will be used to evaluate the grant applications submitted for consideration. Just keep in mind that you'll still have to wait for your summary statement before you resubmit, and you may have to revise your application further based on what reviewers note. Foster a culture of improvement, growth, and recognition. Delivering effective and actionable performance reviews is key to employee growth and organizational success. Example Paragraphs “Michael’s technical Sample Proposal Review Worksheet Developed by Stephanie McAuliffe: The David and Lucile Packard Foundation for the July Institute for New Grantmakers, 2002 1. This form may be used when you cannot perform an on-site visit of your grantee(s). NIH separates the review process from funding decisions. Feb 27, 2025 · Human Resources 75 effective Performance Review Phrases examples in 2025 You need to find the right words for filling in your performance reviews. 101 Positive Review Examples (Copy and Paste) Writing a positive review can be a great way to show appreciation for a product, service, or experience that you enjoyed. This article provides performance review phrases and paragraph examples for assessing teamwork skills. Excellence of the Science), the risks associated with the research, the resources requested and the value added by any project partners. However, note that the Scientific Review Officer (SRO) managing your specific review meeting may provide additional, or even different, information than what is found on this page. A grant that you read earlier may not seem so great compared to later ones (or vice versa). Oct 30, 2024 · Discover 120 effective performance review phrases to provide clear, constructive feedback in 2024. Well-written performance review phrases show specific examples of behavior and impact, rather than vague statements about an employee’s work. It’s in this vital step that you select the very best applica ts and begin your relationship with your grantees. The paper is generally well written and structured. This blog covers performance review examples, phrases, and questions to help managers conduct meaningful evaluations. I include it here so you can see the level of detail/discussion I expect for your letter. May 1, 2024 · Discover a comprehensive list of 100 powerful and insightful performance review phrases and comments to enhance your evaluation process. Jun 22, 2022 · 1. Use our list of 42 sample phrases for negative performance reviews to drive improvement. When applying to the NIH, this document is called a Summary Statement. In this paper, we present a multi-methods analysis of responses from grant applicants regarding their Jun 13, 2024 · Improve your customer reviews with these 17 positive review examples and copy paste review response templates. Written comments and numerical scores must align. Performance Review Comments Example These sample performance review comments provide balanced feedback about employee performance: “Michael excels at customer service and has received praise from 15 clients this quarter. When reviewing each grant, please weigh both the scientific and repurposing merits of the proposed research, and make sure the PI has addressed the comments/concerns from the Proposal review stage, either directly or in the body of Mar 14, 2025 · Consolidated List of Reviewer Documents This page provides guidance for reviewers on the assessment of specific review elements as well as review meeting associated tasks. Reviewers are critical to our mission to see that NIH grant applications receive, fair, independent, expert, and timely scientific reviews. Here you can find an overview of sample comments and examples for the most common review decisions: ‘minor revisions’, ‘major revisions’, ‘revise and resubmit’ and ‘reject’ decisions. Enhance career development with performance reviews. We got you covered in this article with examples that can inspire your comments. In the entrance conference, the awarding agency and recipient team members will discuss the objectives of the site visit, business processes that will be reviewed, the timeline of the review and how grant-related documentation will be assembled for the The grant review process is a critical component of funding for non-profit organizations, academic institutions, and community projects. It serves as a bridge between the aspirations of grant seekers and the resources provided by funding bodies. In this article, we provide 60 example phrases and 5 customizable response templates to help you A comprehensive description of the Foundation’s merit review process is available on the NSF website. The sponsor’s format should be Given the paucity of data surrounding grant review feedback, particularly from an applicant’s perspective, we created a survey for research scientists that asked applicant respondents to rate and comment on the review feedback they received on their most recent submission. Use these ready-to-go phrases to provide helpful, constructive peer evaluations. What is the applicant organization proposing to do? a. Performance Review Phrases During the Grant Review Group Meeting, staff & members checks the matrix to ensure the scores “add up” and that all reviewer comments are legible, on target, constructive, precise, and provide adequate justification. Performance reviews help managers and employees have meaningful conversations about work quality, achievements, and areas for improvement. lccf. Mar 24, 2025 · Learn how to give effective feedback with our top examples of performance review feedback. Learning From Reviewer Comments: Tips for Preparing Research Grant Proposals are subject to expert review. IDEAS Sample Comments for General – Positive • Your proposal is very well-written. e. It will include your overall impact score, strengths and weaknesses, areas of concern, and a recommended budget. Mar 17, 2021 · The primary goal of the peer review of research grant proposals is to evaluate their quality for the funding agency. Performance review sample phrases for Accountant to write a feedback about performance appraisal. May 21, 2025 · Learn how grantmakers can improve the grant review process with these key principles and specific tactics. If you agree to participate, please sign below and return this form via email. Sample Grant Applications With the gracious permission of successful investigators, some NIH institutes have provided samples of funded applications, summary statements, and more. Use these proven comments to boost employee growth and engagement. Checklist for Desk Audit of Grant Contracts This is a sample desk audit form that you may choose to use and adapt for your own purposes. After you have read and initially scored your proposals, you may Aug 16, 2024 · National Advisory Councils or Boards perform the second level of peer review for research grant applications and offer advice and recommendations on policy and program development, program implementation, evaluation, and other matters of significance to the mission and goals of the respective Institutes or Centers (ICs). Mar 11, 2016 · Since 2012, I have served on six federal grant review committees. Jan 24, 2020 · Free, expert grant proposal tips cover how to tighten writing, organize content, review and edit, polish a final submission, develop your career, and more. Feb 7, 2025 · Understanding the grant review process is the first step toward crafting a proposal that resonates with reviewers. After all, you Setting the Right Tone Part 1 Positive Phrases That Can Be Used in a Performance Review Part 2 How to Highlight an Employee’s Strengths with Specific Examples Part 3 Example Comments to Include to Provide Constructive Feedback Part 4 Structuring Your Comments Part 5 Using Examples in Comments Part 6 Encouraging Continuous Development Part 7 Writing Effective Critiques for Research Applications This document provides guidance for reviewers on preparing critiques that best support informed funding decisions by institutes and give clear feedback to investigators. Guide the assessment by starting with a great application Before the review process even begins, it’s crucial that you have a strong foundation––an accessible, intuitive application that provides your reviewers with all the information they need to easily assess each application. However, in my opinion the paper has some shortcomings in regards to some data analyses and text, and I feel this unique dataset has not been utilized to its full extent. A sample Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) proposal by the Family Service Association in Riverside, California illustrates a strong application for a block grant focused on youth development. Learn how to analyze, respond, revise, seek feedback, submit, and learn from reviewer comments in NSF grant proposals. Rubin, Ph. This page provides guidance for reviewers on the assessment of specific review elements as well as review meeting associated tasks. Oct 10, 2024 · Sample Letters of Grant Approval Before we dive into the specifics, it’s important to note that while grant approval letters may vary in length and level of detail depending on the funding organization and grant program, they generally follow a similar format and hit upon a few key points. Good feedback helps employees know where they excel and where they need to improve. Learn how to interpret your NIH summary statement for information about the review, the reviewers’ critiques, and your score. Different grants have distinct eligibility criteria, priorities, and guidelines that must be meticulously reviewed. Embedded in this process are core strategies that are fundamental to the fulfillment of NSF’s mission. Responding to these reviews not only shows appreciation but also strengthens relationships with your customers. Oct 20, 2021 · Learn important questions to use when asking colleagues and reviewers for feedback on your scientific or medical grant proposals When responding to positive reviews, you want to express gratitude, reinforce the positive aspects praised by the customer, and encourage ongoing feedback and engagement. The review process ensures that the most promising research is funded by having reviewers evaluate the scientific merit of applications in a fair, independent, expert, and unbiased manner. Jul 17, 2025 · NIH Center for Scientific Review (CSR)Access data visualizations, reports, and analytical tools to track progress. Elevate your performance reviews with our 170+ examples to help you make an impact. org on the Queries and Research page (http Aug 3, 2023 · WRITING YOUR REVIEW Evaluate appropriateness of the approach (study design, sample, data collection, outcome, statistical analysis, sample size, feasibility) Look at Annals article grant checklist (next slide) Assess each of the review criteria Write up strengths and weaknesses of each Give a separate score for each (score should reflect your Many scientists are struggling with a deluge of requests to review grant applications that they increasingly have to refuse. Sample Grant Applications & Review Processes OPD SharePoint site: A growing repository that will include sample documents such as mentoring plans, facilities, NSF broader impact statements, as well as samples of prior successful proposals and current literature on education The Grantsmanship Center's Library of Winning Grant Proposals: Recently funded, top-ranked grant proposals in a wide Oct 19, 2023 · The following guidance documents and examples of forms are intended to help reviewers navigate the tasks expected of them at different stages of the review process. If your grant review process is wasting energy or arriving at poor A vigorous, fair, and intentional review process for grant applications is therefore essential. Here are a few tips for Taking the Mystery Out of Filing Comments on Proposed Rules. Use these 53 performance review examples to deliver clear and thoughtful messages to employees. Peer review has two important outputs: Learning from Reviewer Comments: Tips for Resubmitting External Grant Proposals Frequent comments from reviewers one might receive are summarized below to provide insights to potential applicants in resubmitting grant proposals – or in preparing a new proposal. However, little is known about whether review feedback achieves this goal. Here are grant review forms which you can refer to in order to make sure that the reasons for grant applications are well-justified according to their purposes. Are its proposed activities likely to achieve these goals? Sep 12, 2023 · Positive feedback is essential for providing a supportive and encouraging environment - be it at school, in the workplace, or with personal relationships. It is intended for use by grant proposals writers in reviewing their own proposals as well as by those reviewing grant proposals prepared by their peers. When providing peer review feedback, it’s important to balance positive and negative comments: this approach allows the reviewer to maintain a friendly tone and helps the recipient feel reassured. Discover effective strategies for responding to reviewer comments on grant applications in 2024. Aug 5, 2025 · Here’s an ultimate collection of impactful performance review examples you can use to transform your annual appraisal process for better results. A simple and well‐structured application format would make it easier to recruit reviewers and improve the quality and Performance evaluation comments shape career trajectories and guide professional development opportunities across organizations. Oct 30, 2023 · Access 70+ peer feedback examples and best practices. Whether it’s for a restaurant, a hotel, a product, or anything in between, a positive review can help others make informed decisions and boost the reputation of the business. kawivq t0l3c 9at rhcoh rabo hawrq 5wrsh 8xhs 6n4nxh iac